奥格拉(伊莉莎白·里瑟 Elizabeth Reaser 饰)的女友离开了她,选择和一个男人在一起,回归了正常的生活,这让奥格拉感到非常的伤心,并且开始产生了自我怀疑。一次偶然中,奥格拉邂逅了名为菲利普(贾斯汀·柯克 Justin Kirk 饰)的男人,菲利普对她的痴迷让奥格拉渐渐重拾了自信,并且开始尝试着和这个男人交往。 被奥格拉迷得神魂颠倒的菲利普决定和女友格蕾丝(格瑞辰·摩尔 Gretchen Mol 饰)分手,可格蕾丝和奥格拉在机缘巧合之下相遇,并且迅速坠入了情网。就这样,奥格拉、格蕾丝和菲利普三人陷入了一段非常荒唐和混乱的三角关系之中。Allegra, an opera-loving writer in New York, eschews commitment, so her girlfriend, Samantha, leaves her. Allegra misses Sam, and resents the accusation that she's afraid to say "I love you," but she's soon involved with two people - Grace and Philip - who, unbeknownst to her, have just broken up with each other. Allegra juggles the two affairs, telling neither about the other; each likes her more and more as her old fears start making her itchy. Things come to a head at an engagement party where Allegra is pinch-hitting as a catering assistant.